Posts tagged nope
Posts tagged nope
After an impossibly high benchmark set by BBC Sherlock, it is an uphill battle for CBS to top the Moftiss version in a way that still stays true to the original Sherlock Holmes stories. Good luck to them, but I’m not hopeful.
” I read the script for Elementary today, and…
i recognize that i am maybe going overboard in support of elementary at this point- i mean, there is absolutely nothing to back me up, except some candids and vague details. but then again, i don’t think i’m terribly unjustified, because a hell of a lot of people are going overboard in their dislike for elementary, and they are mostly basing it off the exact same set of information. or lack thereof.
listen, i know a lot of people have found sherlock holmes through bbc’s sherlock. that’s awesome! i sincerely hope a lot of the fanbase has now taken the time to read the canon, which is amazing, or at least watch the granada series, which is wonderfully accurate. but going into elementary all “but it’s not sherlock!! but they are ripping off sherlock!!! omg it is sooo not as good as sherlock NOTHING IS AS GOOD nothing will EVER be as good HOW DARE CBS TRY TO DO THEIR OWN SHOW” is kind of like insane.
there have been a lot of sherlock holmes adaptations. seriously. there have been SO FUCKING MANY sherlock holmes adaptations. there is a wikipedia article entirely about the many and varied versions of this character, and these stories, that have been made throughout the 100+ years since the canon was written. comparing any particular one to any other is basically pointless.
i can only speak for myself, and i know that i’ve got some bias, because i’ve hardly ever run across versions of holmes i didn’t care for. (so far, it’s only been novels. there is a lot of crappy fiction written about Our Hero.) but i sincerely enjoy a hell of a lot of different holmes shows/movies, and most of them have very little in common with each other apart from the names of the characters.
hell, just take guy ritchie’s version and compare it to the bbc. those are the two most recognizable versions of holmes at the moment, and both are SO FUCKING DIFFERENT not only from each other, but also from the source material, that it’s kind of like laughable. seriously. you may personally enjoy one more than the other, but that doesn’t make them the “right” one or the “real” one. it doesn’t invalidate the one you don’t love the absolute most. you can, in fact, love more than one at once.
maybe elementary will really suck. i hope it doesn’t! i don’t think it will. but it might. but, y’know, i’m going to try to actually watch it first, before i decide that.
and if your reason for thinking it sucks is because it isn’t sherlock, or it isn’t enough like sherlock, or it’s too much like sherlock, or jonny lee miller just doesn’t have the right cheekbones… then i sort of kind of want you to just shut your pie hole, please.
“you won’t see me …”
Reblogging for Arbitrary Aubergine because it always reminds me of her…
nonverbal communication for the win
This little moment is one of my favorite things. Speaks so much about their relationship without a word being spoken.
8 Year old girl from Dublin tries to get her school demolished… Just listen.